For businesses embarking upon pivotal and difficult foundational change (like this whole social-media-integration-into-business thing), there are distinct stages that very closely resemble the traditional “stages of grief” we’ve come to know around loss in our personal lives.
The people stewarding this change are often right in the thick of these phases, and experiencing these emotions throughout. It’s unpopular sometimes to talk about emotion in context of business, but the reality is that change is emotional. It challenges people’s assumptions, understanding, ego, comfort and familiarity, and tangible experiences. All of those things bring up emotional context that, in turn, affect the processes we build and the decisions we make.
In context of someone like a social strategist or someone engaged in shifting the culture and design of a business, it’s important to not only recognize the stages and their characteristics, but their role in helping guide the organization from one phase to the next, and shorten the time from denial to acceptance. If you can identify where you, your clients, or your organization sit now, it’s easier to plan for what might be coming next. Here’s a bit about what I mean.
Phase 1 – Denial: This isn’t happening!
Social media isn’t part of a serious business strategy. It’s just a fad. The internet and social media are for only young hipsters, or only for personal use, or simply about sharing what we had for lunch or what our cat is doing.
This is still largely the mindset of some businesses, and the person or people that are bringing the message of change are often the ones that get vilified for putting it forward. Denial stems largely from fear: fear of looking uninformed, fear of being obsolete, fear of having to relearn things we’ve known and done for a long time. A key characteristic or behavior to watch for in this phase is dismissiveness.
Phase 2 – Bargaining: Can we make this not happen?
The first reaction once we end up seeing and feeling the urgency if we aren’t ready for it is to quickly try to focus our attention elsewhere. It could be taking extreme measures to make it go away, like blocking access to social media sites completely for employees. It could be more subtle, like beefing up efforts for familiar strategies that may or may not be as effective as they once were, like running a new advertising campaign or buying an email list and hoping.
It could be looking for the magic cure, too, like simply shoving all the social media stuff to the intern, or hiring a consultant or an agency to just “take care of it for you” without wanting to invest much of your own effort. The key characteristic here is avoidance, where you might be willing to acknowledge that something exists, but as long as it’s someone else’s problem, it’s out of sight, out of mind.
Phase 3 – Anger: Why the hell is this happening?
Once we start feeling the pressure to change and any kind of urgency around it, one of the first instincts we have is to get mad at the change itself. Why it’s happening to us, why now, why we have to be the ones to deal with it. We’ll get angry at the effort its going to take, decry social media as a waste of time and resources, or take aim at the people that are bringing it to light (otherwise known as shooting the messenger), sometimes to the detriment to teamwork and communication.
During this phase, you’ll observe an awful lot of resentment, both toward the nature of the change and the ideas contained within, no matter how simple they might be. Citations will be toward all sorts of statistics citing social media disasters, productivity loss, or poor execution. Tone in communication will be of strong resistance, questioning, and perhaps a premature demand for the elusive “return on investment” of social media and social business.
Phase 4 – Despair: This is impossible.
So many businesses understand this state all too well, and are stuck right in the midst of it. We’re overwhelmed by the possibilities, for better or for worse. Even if we can see the upside of what social media can do for us, it feels so far away and so distant that we just aren’t sure we could get there if we tried. Or worse yet, we’ll see absolutely every obstacle in our way, and overreact to both their size and potential impact.
Defeat is the name of the game while you struggle through this phase. Keep a sharp eye out for the dreaded “can’t” and “won’t” phrases, or generalizations and blanket statements that either over-inflate the challenges disproportionate to reality (“it’s impossible to measure!”), or counter every possibility with a “yes, but….”. You might also observe change agents in this phase entering into deep thinking and over analysis that can grind momentum to a halt, or expressing remorse for having not faced up to the emerging world of social media sooner and panicking because they’re “late to the game”.
Phase 5 – Acceptance and Hope: Maybe we can do this after all…
Acceptance is rarely met with an epiphany. More often, accepting and moving into an optimistic, hopeful place about an impending business change is a gradual tip of the scales, where resistance slowly begins to give way to progress, in little pieces. You’ll start to hear people describe the situation not in terms of impossibilities, but in terms of where we go from here, and how we might get there. The potential will gradually outweigh the risks and downsides, or the risks will at least begin to feel as though they’re a manageable part of a realistic whole.
Openness is what you’ll find here; not exuberance, usually, but quiet willingness to try things. To test concepts and explore alternatives, like writing social media guidelines or forming a steering committee. You’ll see a gradual increase in awareness and clarity on the part of the participants, and a certain cohesiveness and sense of momentum will emerge.
Individuals and groups alike will start to adapt their behavior and processes to new normals, and you might see more people volunteer to participate in social programs. Teams and leaders will both exercise objective and critical thought when faced with a challenge, and even be willing to tackle them head on. You’ll all apply patience and perseverance to the process, embracing that it’s indeed a journey, not a destination.
Moving Through the Phases
Helping move people through change management means being able to put unfamiliar concepts into terms that are familiar, and stemming the ebb and flow of panic with grounded ideas that feel like they’re within reach. Try these tricks on for size:
Back it up: Illustrate practical examples of social media in action for business, and highlight some of the rich data and research emerging about its use and adoption.
Relate it personally: Show how social media is more ingrained in our web personal habits than we might think or identify. Do a Google search for any old topic, and find how near the top the blog posts are, or observe the tweets and YouTube videos showing in the real-time search for everyday topics.
Draw familiar parallels: Relate social media to other pivotal but eventual changes, such as the emergence of the web itself (remember when we didn’t think we needed a website?). Talk about how much we had to learn to adapt to other disruptive process changes, like working email into our daily routines.
Observe the facts: Emotion, whether we plan on it or not, plays into our business decisions all the time. Observing simply the known facts of a situation – and getting objective help to do so if needed – can help take some of the personal perspective out of the process and instead help evaluate the potential upsides, obstacles, and open questions that can help lay a realistic and manageable plan for change.
Focus only on the next step: Skip year-long plans right now and focus on the next 3 months. If you can see the next milestone or checkpoint, it’s much easier to say “hey, I can see doing almost anything for 90 days”.
Change Is a Constant
How many times have you heard that?
But it’s true. Change isn’t an absolute, neither is “social media success”. You aren’t ever really “done”. It’s something you experience, and it definitely has identifiable cycles from initial identification to eventual adoption. And if you know what you’re in for, you can better plan to tackle what might be coming next.
As we move through this business renaissance we’re experiencing thanks to the combination of the internet itself, the level-set of social networks and the rise in ubiquitous and fluid content, we’ll ride through these phases many times over. But awareness of the cycle can actually help us navigate these changing waters with grace, with a keen awareness of our surroundings, and with the knowledge that there is a place to land on the other side.
What say you?
WOW Amber, this hits the nail directly on the head! So many of the people I meet are struggling with “doing social media”.
The “it’s a waste of time…what will it do for us…the infamous what’s the ROI” are often some of the first objections I hear, to the point that, even when I recently gave very concrete examples to someone, they simply said: “I don’t believe it.” (These are the people that I calmly and cheerfully smile with and move on:)
I think the big stickler is indeed the Phase 4 your outline: the despair, which I call “possibilities paralysis”. When I’m working with clients who have moved to this phase, we inevitably hit the brick wall of, “how can I possibly do it all? It’s too much…takes too much time…not enough hours in the day…and so on and so on and so on…”
Here’s where the “acceptance and hope” phase is best tackled with what I call small manageable chunks of improvement and movement. When people try to tackle the whole enchilada at once, the despair level is off the charts. When we can break things down into simple sequential steps, then your comment:
“Focus only on the next step: Skip year-long plans right now and focus on the next 3 months. If you can see the next milestone or checkpoint, it’s much easier to say “hey, I can see doing almost anything for 90 days”, makes the most sense of all. Thanks Amber: great perspective. Cheers! Kaarina
WOW Amber, this hits the nail directly on the head! So many of the people I meet are struggling with “doing social media”.
The “it’s a waste of time…what will it do for us…the infamous what’s the ROI” are often some of the first objections I hear, to the point that, even when I recently gave very concrete examples to someone, they simply said: “I don’t believe it.” (These are the people that I calmly and cheerfully smile with and move on:)
I think the big stickler is indeed the Phase 4 your outline: the despair, which I call “possibilities paralysis”. When I’m working with clients who have moved to this phase, we inevitably hit the brick wall of, “how can I possibly do it all? It’s too much…takes too much time…not enough hours in the day…and so on and so on and so on…”
Here’s where the “acceptance and hope” phase is best tackled with what I call small manageable chunks of improvement and movement. When people try to tackle the whole enchilada at once, the despair level is off the charts. When we can break things down into simple sequential steps, then your comment:
“Focus only on the next step: Skip year-long plans right now and focus on the next 3 months. If you can see the next milestone or checkpoint, it’s much easier to say “hey, I can see doing almost anything for 90 days”, makes the most sense of all. Thanks Amber: great perspective. Cheers! Kaarina
Haha sorry Amber, excellent post, but your first point made me almost spew water onto the MacBook. It’s so true, Denial is a big one all though I as a small business owner didn’t have this because my real comfort is online even though I have multiple brick and mortar businesses. So, needless to say I love the aspect of social media and what it can do for business, I’ve written about my social media successes enough to the point where I couldn’t imagine living without it.
Excellent article Amber, thank you.
Haha sorry Amber, excellent post, but your first point made me almost spew water onto the MacBook. It’s so true, Denial is a big one all though I as a small business owner didn’t have this because my real comfort is online even though I have multiple brick and mortar businesses. So, needless to say I love the aspect of social media and what it can do for business, I’ve written about my social media successes enough to the point where I couldn’t imagine living without it.
Excellent article Amber, thank you.
Haha sorry Amber, excellent post, but your first point made me almost spew water onto the MacBook. It’s so true, Denial is a big one all though I as a small business owner didn’t have this because my real comfort is online even though I have multiple brick and mortar businesses. So, needless to say I love the aspect of social media and what it can do for business, I’ve written about my social media successes enough to the point where I couldn’t imagine living without it.
Excellent article Amber, thank you.
Definitely been through these phases and help my social media clients pass through them too. Hardest one is getting over the first part, once over that I tend to find everyone wants things rapidly, and as you point out any relationships worth building take time and effort.
i’ve been stuck at the despair phase for quite a while.
i’ve been stuck at the despair phase for quite a while.
In my experience, phase 3 is the biggest hurdle: it’s the “Whaddya mean” people are tweeting about us (insert brand), followed by “We have to what” (engage)? and “Why do we have to respond ??”. This is also the longest phase and the moment when a Communications’ team unites together around social media or … doesn’t. Great post, tnx
Excellent post – it has ‘Change’ in a nutshell – whether it be social media or anything else …. especially in business
Hi Amber! I absolutely love the fresh way you’ve framed this discussion!! Brilliant, impressive analogy. I’m going to be linking to this!
Amber my friend, you missed one step after acceptance: Territoriality. In just about every corporation under the sun faces a huge argument (and this holds true whether the corporation handles social media in-house or externally through agencies). PR and Marketing will be at each others’ throats to claim ownership of social media. Each feel they have the “right” to social media ownership and they do, but so does the janitor. Everyone has a right to it, and at some point a champion must be named who will arbitrate over who “owns” which sliver of social media.
So many great points here, Amber and I’ve seen them all at work. I have taken to presenting plans in three month increments for the reason you stated. Managers aren’t used to long term commitments. They’re uncomfortable with social media to begin with; they don’t want to think that they”ll have to live with this pain in the ass any longer than they have to. They’re used to thinking in terms of campaigns that have a beginning and an end. The trick is to show some incremental results and like leaving a trail of breadcrumbs (or sweet tweets), lead them to “acceptance.”
I’m a former family counselor who ran a grief support group. This is brilliant. My first response was to laugh out loud, not in a negative way, but because it’s too true.
One of the very first things I do when I speak to CEO groups is say, “Let’s get the baggage out in the open.” And I let them all talk for 20 minutes or so on why they’re ignoring the web, altogether. Last year, I spoke to 150 Vistage groups and in every, single group, at least 25% of the members truly believe their customers aren’t online.
We live in a bubble where we think everyone gets it and is moving through your phases. But the reality is that most are still in denial.
Thanks for the spot on description of what business owners go through – My business is specifically designed to help business owners get through these stages. I hold their hand and tell them it is ok to press the button or add their phone number etc http://www.socialmediamadesimple.info
I need to give this to every single client I start working with. (okay, maybe shortened a bit)…but this is just downright brilliant (and spot on). Just getting someone through the why and how of social is the toughest struggle, but when they get it, it makes it so worth it!
This is really cool Amber how you’re helping people battle the three-headed beast that is called – Fear of rejection, fear of failure, and fear of being wrong.
In my perspective, these are what stop people from really kicking some ass online. Well, laziness too. But even laziness can be the by product of wanting to avoid that three-headed beast. But instead of calling it laziness or being scared, we dress up these feelings with a term like “procrastination” so that we can delude ourselves and others.
But people like you, are helping people like me realize that delusion is the path to nowhere. Thanks for sharing your insights here Amber!
Sharp observation, Amber and profoundly shared. Gave me an of-course, slap-forehead moment seeing it in the company I love to work for.
In private life, social media has become useful, ubiquitous, and boring, like air. So much that another article of yours inspired the very comparison, the air as the first social media http://x.co/Wonb
Great analogy! I liked what you said about the end, about looking 3 months ahead, not 1 year. Small steps make a great distance. If you can accomplish one small thing, you’ll feel better about accomplishing another small thing, and so on.
Great analogy! I liked what you said about the end, about looking 3 months ahead, not 1 year. Small steps make a great distance. If you can accomplish one small thing, you’ll feel better about accomplishing another small thing, and so on.
For me it looks different: phase 1 – client denies and resents social media, phase 2 – client develops ridiculous expectations, like getting bazillion of click-through to their website in one week from social media for less than 5 dollars, phase 3 – client performs classical “I told you so”
What a great post – have lived and am living this cycle. Like other posters have said Phase 4 is the biggest bear – slicing up the options and attacking them one by one as opposed to seeing the mountain and giving up before a step.
The other challenge is that there are so many social charlatans out there – people who claim experience, understanding but have neither, nor do they have any talent for execution nor the maturity to navigate the risks like an adult. Finding the right talent, partners is a tall order.
Great thoughts Amber. This analogy really sums it up because I think we’ve all been through these stages before. Personally, I’m still working through mine. 🙂 Much like anything else, you have to try to look through and focus on the good things that will eventually come. Much like when someone passes away, and you struggle with grief, you have to find a way to punch through the wall and come out on the other side. Definitely the kind of pick up I needed this morning.
Great article and very true! We had some of this when sitting down to discuss our social media strategy, it can be very overwhelming, especially for people who are just starting to integrate it into their business strategies.
surety bail bond
Excellent article. I think I’m at Phase 4. But, since I definitely recognize Phases 1,2 and 3, then I’m hopeful Phase 5 is just around the corner! Thanks for a timely article. Retweeting now…
Hi Amber.
I like very much your post. That’s so true of all changes. And I can see everyday in organizations that wonder what to do with social media.
But that’s also the case with ‘leading edge organizations”
But wait – Microsoft went through the same process with Linux?
And Google? What stage is it in now regarding social media?…
Look forward to your next post
Ah, just what we social media managers need…a 12-Step program. 🙂 Now we just need our own Serenity prayer!
Right on target, Amber – thanks for a FAB post! It’s so frustrating to be the “social media person” at a company (or for a client) that either wants to stick their fingers in their ears and yell “LALALALA, I’m not LISTENING!” or, on the other end of spectrum, thinks it’s a silver bullet and the end to all their marketing woes (“Dell made a million bucks through Twitter, why can’t we?”). The trick is to demonstrate something tangible to the nay-sayers while continually managing expectations in order to (hopefully) avoid the Despair stage (“Why isn’t this working???”). Easier said than done, right? 😉
Denial for me was very hard for The first 5 yrs…I was never apart from my husband/ till one day he’s absence affected me, not denial but accepting that he was gone and never to return…when 5 yrs went by then the
other stages started working in my life.
Thank you for sharing that I just simply was going through the nature of living.
Wow! Excellent post! I can really relate with the post… I could still remember when I was just learning SEO… Thanks for sharing… It was really a wonderful read…
Quite brilliant, Amber. Thank you. I’ll be sharing this with colleagues and I can see myself giving the link to clients, especially the business owners, to reassure them that I have not invited them onto a completely nutty journey just because some people in their team are behaving oddly.
Gini’s comment is spot on too. I make a point of challenging that “our clients aren’t there” view up front. I ask “just let me get clear on this, have you researched that is it is your assumption?” But I say it with a smile, because I know their “opinion” is often (usually?) a cover for a deeper seated resistance. I believe it’s important that the others who are better disposed hear that exchange so the project doesn’t get scuttled once you are out of the building.
I love the “stages” layout! I have been dealing with similar feelings lately when it comes to social media. Makes life easier and more difficult all at the same time.
indianapolis auto dealers
Great post!
Great post, Amber!
I think there is another phase for some folks who are skilled at social media but working in other roles at companies they care about that are still mired deeply in the denial phase. They’ll likely be monitoring their company’s brand on their own time, witnessing undefended brand attack swarms come in from Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and, though less frequently, LinkedIn, and feel utterly helpless. All they can really do because they’re not sitting at the right place in the org chart is bury their heads in their hands and sigh. I think this might be termed as the “WTF!” phase. Multi-skilled visionaries, which every large corporate culture has as employees but seldom consults, clearly recognize that raising issues outside established lines of authority will result in a “shoot the messenger” action, so they just keep quiet and hope that somebody “up there” will catch a clue.
Rigid, immense corporate hierarchies defy optimum levels of internal knowledge management and leveraging of in-house skills, most often as a result of turf protectionism. The bigger and more complex the org chart, the harder it is for people to offer up skills and expertise they brought with them or have developed outside their assigned roles. In some of the bigger, monolithic corporate cultures, having an outwardly-focused social media plan is probably not enough; it may not even be the first necessary step. I think in such instances there needs to first be an internal social media plan and system (Yammer?) implemented as a form of social media introduction and to raise comfort levels and requisite understandings throughout the organization – a “denial phase breaker,” so to speak – before a full-blown dive into the social media pool should be attempted.
In a small business in which every internal actor knows all the other internal actors, social media is an easier “sell” because it doesn’t differ much from how communication functions in-house: socially.
This is one of the best articles I have read. True, SMM is downheartening at times but one must soldier on. Stay strong and battle through the troughs. Thanks Amber 🙂
Thank you for a awesome article.You have given me some ideas and a different way to to write articles.
Thanks
vCommissionComputer Affiliate Programs
Type your comment here.
good
I couldn’t agree more with this analogy. Social Media is difficult to accept, but I believe it’s here to stay, so the sooner we move on to the last stage and embrace it, the better off we’ll be!
indianapolis seo
awesome article Amber! Thanks!
Nice post! very interesting! I couldn’t read through this article fluidly. The writing was a little jagged. As I was reading the post I started thinking “I wonder how this company makes money?” Anways, Cheers.
So true: social media adoption can be an emotional business. I think I’ve been successful helping clients through it because I’m calm, I let them express their fears and negativity, I give them space – and then when they’re ready, keen and motivated, we move forward. It’s very important to reassure them through the whole process. Thanks for the good post.
I think these steps are right on, Social Media is here to stay and the better companies can understand how to utilize it correctly, the more successful can be.
mobile solutions