We’ve talked a lot here in the last few months about some of the nuts and bolts of social media strategy and execution.
Stuff like time management and goal setting and measurement.
But the real key to getting social media established in your organization isn’t just having the toolbelt of skills and tactics and ideas. You need to be accountable what you deliver, other than just a vision and crossed fingers.
Objectives and Strategy
If you don’t know what constitutes a measurable objective, it’s time to learn. And if your social media strategy is lacking, buckle down and make it better. If you want your social media efforts to be taken seriously , treat them as such. Approach them as you would any other business endeavor that requires investment of time, intellect, and resources.
Shortchange the planning piece, and you’re just tinkering. And good luck getting the boss or the board or the client to take you seriously.
Practical Measurement
Please stop telling me you can’t measure social media. Yes you can. You can measure it as well as we’ve ever been able to measure things that impact the sales channel but are not the sales channel themselves. Communications. Customer service. Business Development. Public relations. Marketing. Infrastructure impact. Cost savings. There are plenty of old ideas that are still applicable, and plenty of new things to try.
Lots of social media measurements are going to be correlative vs. causal. Meaning you’ll be able to show that your social media efforts align with progress toward other goals, but that you won’t usually be able to prove that social media is the only thing that drove that progress. But so too with any of the other things I mentioned. That’s the nature of business infrastructure. It’s all related and interdependent.
The problem is that this requires systems thinking, and dedicated work, and too many folks are stopping at the “this is hard and I don’t know how so I’m going to blame the medium”. But no one said you had to nail it perfectly out of the gate. Get in and get your hands dirty, and learn.
Behavior (and Consequences)
What you put on the internet stays on the internet. Do we really need more reminders of that? If you’re representing your company, your personal self, or a balance of both, it’s not social media’s fault if you screw that up. It’s yours.
The instantaneous nature of online communication means it’s far too easy to leave your filters at the door and just pop off about whatever’s on your noggin. But there are real people and businesses at the other end of your communications. And that goes for you as an individual, and you as a business. Just because you can put it out there in real time doesn’t mean you should. Good judgment is needed as much now as ever. Maybe more.
Rushing headlong into social media without any consideration for the culture, investment, risks, cost of success (yes, that’s real), resources, and other business implications is just plain silly. The web will still be here in a few months while you get your ducks in a row, okay?
Responsibility for Outcomes
It’s wonderful to be innovative. Creative. Experiment. I’m a huge proponent for those things, and always have been.
But that means you’ve got to own the results of your work, even if they’re not what you’d hoped for. It’s easy to own success. It takes courage and solid footing to own the “learning opportunities” that come with missing the mark. I’m not talking always about taking the personal blame (though sometimes that’s appropriate), but first owning up to mistakes or shortfalls, then the most important bit:
Making a commitment to do something about them.
Learning and Adjustment
Listening isn’t enough. Engaging isn’t enough. Measuring isn’t enough. You don’t win a prize for doing any of those things alone.
The entire point of all of this stuff is to absorb, learn, and glean insights about how to make your business better for both you and your customers. Listening begets engagement in order to shape information and experiences. Measuring helps you see how well you’re doing with either. But the real gold is a part that only a human can do, and in the part that’ll be unique to each business: figuring out how what you hear, say, and measure has an impact on your entire business. Not just the social media part.
That might require something as old-fashioned as a meeting, or a discussion. Some analysis and critical thinking, or getting help with that piece. That might require talking to people in other departments that you’ve never met. It might mean having a tough conversation with your boss to kill a poor performing initiative, or stick with a new one that’s not there yet, but shows promise.
A Court of Our Peers?
I happen to think we’d all be a bit better served if we stopped standing in such knee-jerk judgment of what everyone else is doing, and instead kept pushing each other to detail all of the above. To deliver the Almighty Case Study that isn’t just filled with shining examples of glory and success, but the ones that help chronicle what went wrong. The hard decisions and choices that came up. The trial and error. The real world learnings that help shape our decisions.
It’s awfully easy to say that someone should have done it differently until you’ve walked in their shoes, or offered a practical alternative yourself. There are so many opportunities for constructive accountability in social media that it utterly fills my mind some days.
We all have a vested interest in weaving social media into business as a legitimate endeavor. But that means we all have a responsibility, too, to model the change that we want. On the spreadsheet, and on the human end. To do the trench work, illustrate our learnings, and demonstrate why it makes sense.
Don’t we? What does accountability mean to you? What else would you add?
Accountability is being able to say “our ideas sucked – let’s try something else” – social media technologies or not – and not blame the tools. Normally companies can sweep it all under the rug, but now it’s all in the open.
.-= Lynette Young´s last blog ..TEDx Talks =-.
Accountability is being able to say “our ideas sucked – let’s try something else” – social media technologies or not – and not blame the tools. Normally companies can sweep it all under the rug, but now it’s all in the open.
.-= Lynette Young´s last blog ..TEDx Talks =-.
Yet another great post, Amber – it’s interesting to see companies who dip their toes in the pool vs. those who dive headfirst into the deep end. Without planning, strategy and eventual execution, neither one will find much success.
Companies need to INTEGRATE AND MEASURE – of course there are things we can measure, and those are the things we need to focus on, instead of dollars generated.
A rising tide floats all boats, I totally agree that by concentrating on what will/could work for YOU instead of trying to play catch up, we’ll see innovations and growth that will benefit everyone.
.-= Hal Lublin´s last blog ..The Brogan Effect =-.
Yet another great post, Amber – it’s interesting to see companies who dip their toes in the pool vs. those who dive headfirst into the deep end. Without planning, strategy and eventual execution, neither one will find much success.
Companies need to INTEGRATE AND MEASURE – of course there are things we can measure, and those are the things we need to focus on, instead of dollars generated.
A rising tide floats all boats, I totally agree that by concentrating on what will/could work for YOU instead of trying to play catch up, we’ll see innovations and growth that will benefit everyone.
.-= Hal Lublin´s last blog ..The Brogan Effect =-.
I’ve very new at being accountable for social media metrics, but it’s obvious that becoming an astute listener is the most important component to any social media plan. It’s easy to get people to agree that your company should engage, and even easier to watch the numbers that don’t really measure anything (followers, friends, etc.) The true test is in creating truly helpful actionable items rather than knee jerk reactions based on what you’ve gleaned.
Deciding to use the tools is not the first, but the second step in a longer path toward bettering business practice. Along the way, it’s best to prepare for a lot of tough or lengthy meetings.
Valuable post!
.-= dmcconnell´s last blog ..No Trouble, No Worry. Talking Dogs Need Not Apply – Traveler’s Commercial =-.
I’ve very new at being accountable for social media metrics, but it’s obvious that becoming an astute listener is the most important component to any social media plan. It’s easy to get people to agree that your company should engage, and even easier to watch the numbers that don’t really measure anything (followers, friends, etc.) The true test is in creating truly helpful actionable items rather than knee jerk reactions based on what you’ve gleaned.
Deciding to use the tools is not the first, but the second step in a longer path toward bettering business practice. Along the way, it’s best to prepare for a lot of tough or lengthy meetings.
Valuable post!
.-= dmcconnell´s last blog ..No Trouble, No Worry. Talking Dogs Need Not Apply – Traveler’s Commercial =-.
I like your tone here Amber. I just listened to you speaking during the SOBCon2010 webinar, so allow me that I can imagine you speaking these words! I was reading Shannon Paul’s post last night and it got me fairly excited. I’m glad to see that you linked to it here. She inspired my writing today as well.
I like the conversation shift toward the weight of strategy that I’m seeing lately. It would appear that the “what’s next” in social media marketing has arrived. I was thrilled as I recognized where this article was headed, it more-or-less validates a lot of the things that have been on my mind about how the “helpers” ought to be helping. Something about your writing today stands out too…I just can’t put my finger on it. Thanks for another great read and the thinking that comes from it!
.-= James Ball´s last blog ..Don’t Destroy Your Social Media ROI In 2010 =-.
I like your tone here Amber. I just listened to you speaking during the SOBCon2010 webinar, so allow me that I can imagine you speaking these words! I was reading Shannon Paul’s post last night and it got me fairly excited. I’m glad to see that you linked to it here. She inspired my writing today as well.
I like the conversation shift toward the weight of strategy that I’m seeing lately. It would appear that the “what’s next” in social media marketing has arrived. I was thrilled as I recognized where this article was headed, it more-or-less validates a lot of the things that have been on my mind about how the “helpers” ought to be helping. Something about your writing today stands out too…I just can’t put my finger on it. Thanks for another great read and the thinking that comes from it!
.-= James Ball´s last blog ..Don’t Destroy Your Social Media ROI In 2010 =-.
“Shortchange the planning and you’re just tinkering.” That is SO right on target. It amazes me to watch companies who would never think of launching a “traditional marketing tactic” without a complete strategy in place literally jumping into the deep end of the social media pool with no plan, no goals, no measurement – and therefore, no success.
Accountability with social media to me means applying the same rigor we’ve always applied when it comes to developing a sound marketing strategy, including planning, implementation, and measurement.
I’m all for experimentation as well – it’s how we learn! But experimentation without a goal is foolhardy – and it’s a poor carpenter who blames his tools when all doesn’t go well.
Great post, Amber!
Caroline
.-= Caroline Melberg´s last blog ..Why Natural Is So Good =-.
“Shortchange the planning and you’re just tinkering.” That is SO right on target. It amazes me to watch companies who would never think of launching a “traditional marketing tactic” without a complete strategy in place literally jumping into the deep end of the social media pool with no plan, no goals, no measurement – and therefore, no success.
Accountability with social media to me means applying the same rigor we’ve always applied when it comes to developing a sound marketing strategy, including planning, implementation, and measurement.
I’m all for experimentation as well – it’s how we learn! But experimentation without a goal is foolhardy – and it’s a poor carpenter who blames his tools when all doesn’t go well.
Great post, Amber!
Caroline
.-= Caroline Melberg´s last blog ..Why Natural Is So Good =-.
Agree! Agree! Agree! Agree! Agree! Agree! Agree! Thank you for posting this! I actually posted a similar perspective, but from the customer. We as customers interacting with brands need to apply some of these techniques when interacting with Brands also.
If we dont stop the gotcha mentality all across the board we are all going to take our ball and bats and go home. One techniques I seem to a lot of traction with is the DM or email conversation, then we agree to talk publicly. People and Brand accounts seem to be surprised, but pleasantly pleased at the interaction.
You are right it takes all: “Listening isn’t enough. Engaging isn’t enough. Measuring isn’t enough” working together to make it work. I would also like to add it takes an eclectic group of skills, backgrounds, experiences, and business units collaborating to make it works also! I think we get a little blinder syndrome when it comes to what skills and where to find the people.
Thanks again for posting the common sense, simple, and constructive advice for all of us!
Agree! Agree! Agree! Agree! Agree! Agree! Agree! Thank you for posting this! I actually posted a similar perspective, but from the customer. We as customers interacting with brands need to apply some of these techniques when interacting with Brands also.
If we dont stop the gotcha mentality all across the board we are all going to take our ball and bats and go home. One techniques I seem to a lot of traction with is the DM or email conversation, then we agree to talk publicly. People and Brand accounts seem to be surprised, but pleasantly pleased at the interaction.
You are right it takes all: “Listening isn’t enough. Engaging isn’t enough. Measuring isn’t enough” working together to make it work. I would also like to add it takes an eclectic group of skills, backgrounds, experiences, and business units collaborating to make it works also! I think we get a little blinder syndrome when it comes to what skills and where to find the people.
Thanks again for posting the common sense, simple, and constructive advice for all of us!
Thank you for saying it!
Finally!
All too often I hear the same complaints from those who have tried and failed and trash the medium… But then I look at some of their posts and see that there are 6 mentions of their brand name, 3 versions of their tag, no conversational tone in their postings, and this is all before I even scroll down the page.
Then they say, well maybe if I run paid ads, and their conversion isn’t as high as they would have liked, thinking that maybe it was their exposure that’s not getting new feedback…
Yes People. Please Be Accountable for all of it and know that it’s all interdependent on each other. Those who are accountable are good at what they do, those who are not… well, I’ll let you figure it out from there…
Oh p.s this post was bookmarked for posterity
Thank you for saying it!
Finally!
All too often I hear the same complaints from those who have tried and failed and trash the medium… But then I look at some of their posts and see that there are 6 mentions of their brand name, 3 versions of their tag, no conversational tone in their postings, and this is all before I even scroll down the page.
Then they say, well maybe if I run paid ads, and their conversion isn’t as high as they would have liked, thinking that maybe it was their exposure that’s not getting new feedback…
Yes People. Please Be Accountable for all of it and know that it’s all interdependent on each other. Those who are accountable are good at what they do, those who are not… well, I’ll let you figure it out from there…
Oh p.s this post was bookmarked for posterity
How to quantify social media marketing is a common question that gets asked. Indeed, planning an effective strategy certainly helps measure the cost of such campaigns. In addition, learning from past experiences and fine-tuning future plans based on those incidences is critical for personal and business development.
How to quantify social media marketing is a common question that gets asked. Indeed, planning an effective strategy certainly helps measure the cost of such campaigns. In addition, learning from past experiences and fine-tuning future plans based on those incidences is critical for personal and business development.
Excellent article! We are moving slowly (on purpose) into social media. Just b/c we can doesn’t always mean we should at least not a rapid clip with no plan! Thanks for the practical “real world” advice. I’m going to send this to some of my “peeps” here at work.
Excellent article! We are moving slowly (on purpose) into social media. Just b/c we can doesn’t always mean we should at least not a rapid clip with no plan! Thanks for the practical “real world” advice. I’m going to send this to some of my “peeps” here at work.
I like the idea of social media being a device that can have accountability rather than a playground of chaos. People love to view social media as a tool to speak, speak, speak. All to often though, they forget to listen. Listening is key! Great post though. It made me think about what I’m doing with social media.
-Eric Saylor
I like the idea of social media being a device that can have accountability rather than a playground of chaos. People love to view social media as a tool to speak, speak, speak. All to often though, they forget to listen. Listening is key! Great post though. It made me think about what I’m doing with social media.
-Eric Saylor
Very comprehensive article. Measuring social media results, as you point out, is so necessary to evaluate a brand’s visibility. Most importantly, measurement results can be most informative in identifying what social media methods work and which ones need adjustments. Not only that, but by analyzing results, brands are doing market research about their target audiences.
.-= MommyBlogExpert´s last blog ..Build-A-Bear Workshop Recognizing Kids in the Community =-.
Very comprehensive article. Measuring social media results, as you point out, is so necessary to evaluate a brand’s visibility. Most importantly, measurement results can be most informative in identifying what social media methods work and which ones need adjustments. Not only that, but by analyzing results, brands are doing market research about their target audiences.
.-= MommyBlogExpert´s last blog ..Build-A-Bear Workshop Recognizing Kids in the Community =-.
Amber, thank you for another sound article. I admire the way you lay out your thoughts without taking shots at others in our space. I’m seeing way too much of that. There is so much success to be experienced, so much to be learned, so much to create, in this space, that it is imperative for all of us to continue learning whatever we can to pave the way for our companies. I believe your tone of being helpful to everyone, to help others understand the big picture, and to offer your knowledge, is the best way to go.
I am excited to see all of the strategy being discussed these days. I have been running around sales and marketing for over 20 years, and know nothing other than to create strategy around marketing and Social Media efforts. Strategy can be learned. No one has to be left out unless they want to be.
Let’s continue to share these messages with the goals of improving and raising the bar for everyone in a non-intimidating and helpful environment.
Again, nice job!
Amber, thank you for another sound article. I admire the way you lay out your thoughts without taking shots at others in our space. I’m seeing way too much of that. There is so much success to be experienced, so much to be learned, so much to create, in this space, that it is imperative for all of us to continue learning whatever we can to pave the way for our companies. I believe your tone of being helpful to everyone, to help others understand the big picture, and to offer your knowledge, is the best way to go.
I am excited to see all of the strategy being discussed these days. I have been running around sales and marketing for over 20 years, and know nothing other than to create strategy around marketing and Social Media efforts. Strategy can be learned. No one has to be left out unless they want to be.
Let’s continue to share these messages with the goals of improving and raising the bar for everyone in a non-intimidating and helpful environment.
Again, nice job!
i have tried social media marketing for getting our new products to be known on the market. it seems to work well specially if the audience is targeted *
i have tried social media marketing for getting our new products to be known on the market. it seems to work well specially if the audience is targeted *